Andrew Tate is emblematic of a new iteration of male supremacist influencers, often referred to as ‘manfluencers’ or ‘misogyny influencers’. Research on the relationship between boys’ consumption of and support for these influencers, and their circulation of regressive gender ideologies, is in its formative stages. This paper explores these issues using focus groups and follow-up interviews with young people (aged 12–17) in four schools in London, England. While many boys ‘othered’ Andrew Tate and condemned his misogyny, several boys simultaneously demonstrated a continuum of support for manospheric content promoting sexist gender roles and exaggerated masculine ideals. We discuss how boys affectively responded to these digital discourses and the role of humour in normalizing the gendered power hierarchies at play. The findings highlight the need for interventions that go beyond condemning single influencers, situating manospheric masculine archetypes within the systemic and increasingly networked subordination of women, femininity, and Queer identities on mainstream platforms.